Close Menu
Raceday S.A.
  • Home
  • NASCAR
  • NHRA
  • IndyCar
  • TMS
  • COTA
  • Trackside
  • Photos
  • Dixie’s Drinks and Eats
Facebook X (Twitter)
Facebook X (Twitter)
Raceday S.A.
  • Home
  • NASCAR
  • NHRA
  • IndyCar
  • TMS
  • COTA
  • Trackside
  • Photos
  • Dixie’s Drinks and Eats
Raceday S.A.
Home»NASCAR»Plaintiffs’ case nears conclusion with questioning of NASCAR chairman Jim France
NASCAR

Plaintiffs’ case nears conclusion with questioning of NASCAR chairman Jim France

racedaysaeditorBy racedaysaeditorDecember 9, 2025Updated:December 11, 2025No Comments4 Mins Read
Share Facebook Twitter Email Copy Link
Follow Us
Facebook X (Twitter)
Share
Facebook Twitter Email Copy Link

By Reid Spencer, NASCAR Wire Service

CHARLOTTE, N.C.—When court adjourned a half-hour later than usual on Tuesday—the seventh day of the “23XI Racing and Front Row Motorsports v. NASCAR” antitrust trial—plaintiffs’ lead attorney Jeff Kessler had just finished his questioning of NASCAR chairman and CEO Jim France.

After establishing that NASCAR is owned by the France family through trusts, with Jim France holding the majority stake, Kessler spent the bulk of his direct examination on team owners’ requests for permanent charters in the 2025 agreement and on the NASCAR board’s ultimate decision not to include an “evergreen” provision in the new agreement. ‘Permanency’ is a term the has been mentioned regularly in various testimonies and is a term that neither sides could agree upon.

Kessler pointed to testimony from Joe Gibbs Racing team owner Heather Gibbs, who testified last week about her 2024 letter to NASCAR requesting team charters. Earlier on Tuesday, the plaintiffs had called Richard Childress Racing team owner Richard Childress as a witness in a similar vein.

Letters from team owners Jack Roush (Roush Fenway Keselowski Racing), Rick Hendrick (Hendrick Motorsports) and Roger Penske (Team Penske) further emphasized the owners’ desire for NASCAR to make the charters a permanent asset, one of the so-called “four pillars” teams had requested on an ongoing basis during the two-and-a-half years of negotiations.

“We did not agree to evergreen or permanent charters, no,” France testified.

Whether the failure to grant permanent charters represented anti-competitive behavior, which the plaintiffs must prove with a preponderance of the evidence, or is simply construed as a negotiating issue is a matter for the jury, which needs to come to a unanimous decision.

NASCAR commissioner Steve Phelps, who preceded Childress on the stand, testified that NASCAR had attempted to address the length-of-charter issue by guaranteeing an additional seven-year charter period beyond the current broadcast rights deal, which expires after the 2031 season.

“I know it’s something the race teams desired,” Phelps said. “What we tried to find was a compromise.”

During the second seven-year term of the 2025 charter agreement, NASCAR has guaranteed that teams will receive at least the same amount of revenue that they get during the first seven years.

“They (the teams) wanted a floor,” Phelps said. “We gave them a floor.”

Phelps also dispelled the notion that NASCAR could dilute the market by adding to the total of 36 charters.

On re-direct, Phelps testified that NASCAR could issue only two new charters to new entities “if and only if a new OEM (car maker) comes in, and if and only if the other chartered teams decided not to bid for those charters.”

The four pillars have been a recurring theme in the plaintiffs’ case. From the outset, team owners—represented by a Team Negotiating Council of Jeff Gordon (Hendrick Motorsports), Dave Alpern (Joe Gibbs Racing), Steve Newmark (former president of Roush Fenway Keselowski Racing) and Curtis Polk (23XI)—consistently asked for 1) more money, 2) voting rights for owners over cost increases, 3) permanent charters and 4) one-third of all new business opportunities.

Teams did get a substantial increase in revenue–$98 million above 2024 levels for an average total money per charter of $12.5 million. To address governance, NASCAR created an Owners Advisory Council, which Phelps said gives teams a seat at the table without voting or veto rights.

The new charter agreement also provides for the creation of a New Business Committee to evaluate new opportunities on a case-by-case basis.

Thirteen of 15 teams signed the 2025 charter agreement. Only 23XI and Front Row did not, choosing to file suit alleging anti-competitive practices on the part of NASCAR and claiming damages under the 2016 charter agreement.

France’s testimony will conclude Wednesday with cross-examination by NASCAR outside counsel Chris Yates and perhaps re-direct by the plaintiffs, who are expected to rest their case after France leaves the stand.

Presiding Judge Kenneth D. Bell said he hoped NASCAR can conclude its case by Friday afternoon, perhaps by paring its witness list. That would leave only closing arguments from both sides before the case goes to the jury.

Share this:

  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
Share. Facebook Twitter Email Copy Link
racedaysaeditor
  • Website

Related Posts

Editor's Picks

A talent for the ages: Kyle Larson adds a third Cup crown

November 8, 2026
Editor's Picks

Ryan Blaney steals Homestead win as Kyle Larson claims NASCAR Cup title

November 8, 2026
NASCAR

Justin Allgaier claims second O’Reilly Series title as Brandon Jones wins Homestead finale

November 7, 2026
NASCAR

Saturday Homestead-Miami Championship Weekend Notebook

November 7, 2026
NASCAR

Kaden Honeycutt charges to Homestead victory and NASCAR Truck Series title

November 6, 2026
Editor's Picks

NASCAR Championship Media Day Notebook

November 5, 2026
Add A Comment

Comments are closed.

RacedaySA Facebook Page
RacedaySA Facebook Page
LATEST NEWS

Teen-age sensation Johnson stepping-up to NTT IndyCar Series with Dale Coyne Racing

November 20, 2026

Todd wins race, title in dramatic fashion at In-N-Out Burger NHRA Finals; Kalitta, Glenn, Herrera also get victories

November 15, 2026

Herrera wins postponed Vegas race; Kalitta, Capps, Glenn and Herrera qualify No. 1 in Pomona

November 14, 2026

Kalitta, Capps, Glenn and Herrera open In-N-Out Burger Finals in provisional No. 1 spots

November 13, 2026

Project Accelerator initiative to support Pierson’s fulltime INDYCAR program with A.J. Foyt Racing

November 12, 2026
RACEDAYSA

Your source for motorsports news, photos and coverage from San Antonio and across Texas, featuring NASCAR, NHRA, INDYCAR and more.

MOTORSPORTS LINKS

NASCAR

NHRA

INDYCAR

Texas Motor Speedway

Circuit of the Americas

FOLLOW RACEDAYSA
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
© 2026 Raceday SA. All Rights Reserved.
  • About Us
  • Contact Us

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.