Close Menu
Raceday S.A.
  • Home
  • NASCAR
  • NHRA
  • IndyCar
  • TMS
  • COTA
  • Trackside
  • Photos
  • Dixie’s Drinks and Eats
Facebook X (Twitter)
Facebook X (Twitter)
Raceday S.A.
  • Home
  • NASCAR
  • NHRA
  • IndyCar
  • TMS
  • COTA
  • Trackside
  • Photos
  • Dixie’s Drinks and Eats
Raceday S.A.
Home»NASCAR»NASCAR antitrust trial starts second week with a blizzard of numbers
NASCAR

NASCAR antitrust trial starts second week with a blizzard of numbers

racedaysaeditorBy racedaysaeditorDecember 8, 2025Updated:December 11, 2025No Comments4 Mins Read
Share Facebook Twitter Email Copy Link
Follow Us
Facebook X (Twitter)
Share
Facebook Twitter Email Copy Link

By Reid Spencer, NASCAR Wire Service

CHARLOTTE, N.C.—In the Western District of North Carolina courthouse on Monday, participants and onlookers in Judge Kenneth D. Bell’s courtroom spent most of the afternoon in “but for” world.

Economist Edward A. Snyder, an expert witness for the plaintiffs in the “23XI Racing and Front Row Motorsports v. NASCAR” antitrust litigation, spent hours on the stand first presenting and then defending his thesis that anti-competitive practices on the part of NASCAR damaged 23XI and Front Row during the period 2021 through 2024.

Plaintiffs used Snyder to try to establish the amount of monetary damages the two race teams have suffered under the 2016 charter agreement during that four-year period. NASCAR’s alleged anti-competitive behavior and the amount of damages, if any, are matters in dispute in the trial.

Snyder contended that 23XI and Front Row both would have made more money and that their organizations would have been worth much more, but for NASCAR’s alleged anti-competitive actions.

Citing issues that have become familiar themes during the proceedings, Snyder pointed to the goodwill or non-compete provisions of the charter agreements with NASCAR Cup Series race teams, the exclusivity clauses in sanctioning agreements with race tracks and the intellectual property restrictions placed on NASCAR’s Gen-7 race cars, which were introduced into the Cup series in 2022.

Snyder based his analysis on the supposition that a competing premier stock car racing series would have been viable by 2021 in “but for” world—had the above provisions not existed.

On cross-examination, however, NASCAR outside counsel Lawrence F. Buterman brought out the fact that no equivalent series had ever come into being in NASCAR’s 77-year history. That was true even before 2016 charter agreements were adopted by Cup Series teams, during a lengthy period when no such restrictions existed.

Using Formula 1 racing as the closest benchmark to NASCAR, and incorporating a multiple of 4.3 times annual earnings, Snyder postulated that 23XI would have made an additional $41 million and Front Row and additional $43 million over the four years in question.

Added to that were Snyder’s calculations of reduction in market values of $163.8 million for 23XI and $96.4 million for Front Row, based on the 4.3 multiplier.

Buterman questioned Snyder of the presumption that NASCAR would have paid its chartered teams an additional $1.06 billion had a rival league actually existed, a figure that was a fundamental part of the calculations.

“I don’t know how NASCAR’s going to respond (to competition),” Snyder acknowledged.

Snyder’s estimates of potential profits and market value also were dependent on raising the share of NASCAR revenues paid to teams from 25 percent (as under the 2016 charter agreement) to 45 percent (the rate Snyder incorporated from F1).

According to the plaintiffs’ own chart, as Buterman pointed out, the amount of revenue F1 paid to its teams in 2023 and 2024 was 37 percent.

Snyder also acknowledged under cross that his estimates did not take into consideration any potential decrease in NASCAR revenues based on competition from a rival series.

Buterman also challenged Snyder’s contention that NASCAR “paid for exclusivity” in its contracts with Cup race tracks. In fact, evidence submitted during trial indicates that NASCAR paid 65 percent of broadcast rights revenue to the tracks before and after exclusivity provisions were added to the sanctioning agreements concurrent with the adoption of the charter system in 2016.

Snyder’s testimony followed the completion of the cross-examination of Race Team Alliance executive director John Marshall, who acknowledged that no other racing series had provided permanent charters to its teams (a prevalent issue in the trial).

Marshall also testified that, after an initial request of an aggregate $720 million annually during 2025 charter negotiations, the majority of NASCAR team owners reacted positively to an offer from NASCAR between $410 million and $451 million in the new 2025 charter agreement, based on a fixed 45 percent of broadcast revenue.

In fact, 13 of the 15 teams signed the 2025 charter agreement. Only 23XI and Front Row did not.

The trial will continue on Tuesday morning with Snyder on the stand. The plaintiffs are expected to call NASCAR commissioner Steve Phelps, Cup Series team owner Richard Childress and NASCAR chairman and CEO Jim France as their next witnesses.

Share this:

  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
NASCAR
Share. Facebook Twitter Email Copy Link
racedaysaeditor
  • Website

Related Posts

Editor's Picks

A talent for the ages: Kyle Larson adds a third Cup crown

November 8, 2026
Editor's Picks

Ryan Blaney steals Homestead win as Kyle Larson claims NASCAR Cup title

November 8, 2026
NASCAR

Justin Allgaier claims second O’Reilly Series title as Brandon Jones wins Homestead finale

November 7, 2026
NASCAR

Saturday Homestead-Miami Championship Weekend Notebook

November 7, 2026
NASCAR

Kaden Honeycutt charges to Homestead victory and NASCAR Truck Series title

November 6, 2026
Editor's Picks

NASCAR Championship Media Day Notebook

November 5, 2026
Add A Comment

Comments are closed.

RacedaySA Facebook Page
RacedaySA Facebook Page
LATEST NEWS

Todd wins race, title in dramatic fashion at In-N-Out Burger NHRA Finals; Kalitta, Glenn, Herrera also get victories

November 15, 2026

Herrera wins postponed Vegas race; Kalitta, Capps, Glenn and Herrera qualify No. 1 in Pomona

November 14, 2026

Kalitta, Capps, Glenn and Herrera open In-N-Out Burger Finals in provisional No. 1 spots

November 13, 2026

Project Accelerator initiative to support Pierson’s fulltime INDYCAR program with A.J. Foyt Racing

November 12, 2026

A talent for the ages: Kyle Larson adds a third Cup crown

November 8, 2026
RACEDAYSA

Your source for motorsports news, photos and coverage from San Antonio and across Texas, featuring NASCAR, NHRA, INDYCAR and more.

MOTORSPORTS LINKS

NASCAR

NHRA

INDYCAR

Texas Motor Speedway

Circuit of the Americas

FOLLOW RACEDAYSA
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
© 2026 Raceday SA. All Rights Reserved.
  • About Us
  • Contact Us

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.